FROM : Phil
DATE : Fri Feb 08 21:06:44 2008
On Feb 8, 2008, at 10:37 AM, Sean McBride wrote:
> On 2/7/08 3:31 PM, Phil said:
>
>> It seems like it would be a significant amount
>> of effort, both in the Apple frameworks and for app developers, to
>> keep a non-trivial application functioning properly to being moved/
>> renamed while running vs. what percentage of users would ever attempt
>> to do this even once.
>
> You're thinking like a programmer. What percentage of users would
> even
> consider that moving a running app could be a problem? Why should it
> be? Many users don't even understand the whole idea of the file
> system
> hierarchy, let alone such subtleties.
Actually I was thinking about it from a user, customer support, and
business standpoint. When I think about scenarios I've dealt with on
my own or in supporting others and this scenario has never come up.
Granted, there are a great many things that users aren't aware of (nor
should they need to be) and I was making the point that it seemed like
a lot of work for a relatively small payback. I just checked several
apps from Apple and 3rd parties and none that I tried works correctly
in this scenario. Anyway, Sanford has users reporting this problem
and he's trying to find a solution which makes perfect sense to me.
Thanks,
Phil
DATE : Fri Feb 08 21:06:44 2008
On Feb 8, 2008, at 10:37 AM, Sean McBride wrote:
> On 2/7/08 3:31 PM, Phil said:
>
>> It seems like it would be a significant amount
>> of effort, both in the Apple frameworks and for app developers, to
>> keep a non-trivial application functioning properly to being moved/
>> renamed while running vs. what percentage of users would ever attempt
>> to do this even once.
>
> You're thinking like a programmer. What percentage of users would
> even
> consider that moving a running app could be a problem? Why should it
> be? Many users don't even understand the whole idea of the file
> system
> hierarchy, let alone such subtleties.
Actually I was thinking about it from a user, customer support, and
business standpoint. When I think about scenarios I've dealt with on
my own or in supporting others and this scenario has never come up.
Granted, there are a great many things that users aren't aware of (nor
should they need to be) and I was making the point that it seemed like
a lot of work for a relatively small payback. I just checked several
apps from Apple and 3rd parties and none that I tried works correctly
in this scenario. Anyway, Sanford has users reporting this problem
and he's trying to find a solution which makes perfect sense to me.
Thanks,
Phil
| Related mails | Author | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Sanford Selznick | Feb 7, 20:50 | |
| Phil | Feb 7, 21:31 | |
| William Bates | Feb 8, 04:28 | |
| Mac Man | Feb 8, 05:38 | |
| Gregory Weston | Feb 8, 13:42 | |
| Sean McBride | Feb 8, 16:37 | |
| Jens Alfke | Feb 8, 18:11 | |
| Kyle Sluder | Feb 8, 18:16 | |
| Phil | Feb 8, 21:06 | |
| William Bates | Feb 8, 22:52 | |
| Stephen Hoffman | Feb 9, 00:19 | |
| Stephen Hoffman | Feb 9, 00:32 |






Cocoa mail archive

