Skip navigation.
 
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]:
FROM : Bill Bumgarner
DATE : Sun Feb 17 21:06:22 2008

On Feb 17, 2008, at 11:15 AM, Gregory Weston wrote:
> See what you're saying? +alloc *or* +allocWithZone:.
>
> See the subject? +alloc. It does not say anything about 
> +allocWithZone:.
>
> See this code?
>
> @interface MyTest : NSObject
> @end
>
> @implementation MyTest
> + (id)alloc
> {
>  NSLog(@"allocating");
>  return [super alloc];
> }
> @end


You would have to override +allocWithZone: to have any kind of 
reliable behavior.  +alloc is a cover for +allocWithZone: with a NULL 
zone.  Not that you would know that from the documentation, 
unfortunately.

Without assuming anything, you would have to override both allocator 
methods;  +alloc and +allocWithZone:.

b.bum

Related mailsAuthorDate
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 15, 22:55
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Adam P Jenkins Feb 16, 00:05
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 16, 00:11
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Hamish Allan Feb 16, 00:26
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 16, 00:39
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 16, 13:56
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 16, 18:11
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 16, 22:16
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 17, 00:28
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 17, 14:25
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 17, 17:13
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 17, 20:15
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 17, 21:06
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 17, 23:28
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Bill Bumgarner Feb 18, 00:05
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Hamish Allan Feb 18, 00:47
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: j o a r Feb 18, 01:47
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 18, 13:53
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Gregory Weston Feb 18, 14:11
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Jeff Johnson Feb 18, 14:46
mlRe: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Alastair Houghton Feb 18, 14:58
ml[Moderator] Re: [Foo new] vs [[Foo alloc] init]: Scott Anguish Feb 18, 20:33