Re: inappropriate questions [tables]

  • On 26 May '08, at 5:14 AM, Sachin Kumar wrote:

    > I feel your response to this question is not appropriate and please do
    > not discourage the developers to post questions by mailing lists.
    > Your mail
    > makes the beginner to hesitate regarding further queries. I do
    > accept that
    > the question is improper, but let us make them to rewrite the
    > question in
    > detail.

    No, Andrew's reply was appropriate. The OP was asking a uselessly
    vague question, which could only be answered by writing a lengthy
    tutorial article or by spending three or four emails extracting the
    details of the situation, either of which is a waste of people's time.

    > We are here in the mailing lists to resolve their issues if possible
    > and encourage the developers but not to criticize them.

    Speak for yourself. Looking through the archives, I don't see a single
    example of you resolving anyone's issues or encouraging other
    developers. You've just been posting exactly the same kinds of
    incredibly vague questions [1] that you now describe as "improper".
    What gives you the right to lecture to someone like Andrew who's
    actually been answering people's questions[2]?

    Here's an example [3]:

    > FROM : Sachin Kumar Tulla
    > DATE : Tue Aug 28 09:33:47 2007
    > Hi all,
    > How to create HyperText in cocoa applications? if possible sample
    > code please.
    > Thanks in advance.

    That's not a question to ask a mailing list; it's a request for
    consulting services, where someone would charge you hundreds of
    dollars an hour to work out the details of what you need and design a
    solution for you. Expecting to get that sort of service from us for
    free is what's inappropriate.

    There's nothing wrong with being a newbie; I've been in that situation
    myself, and I still am sometimes when I learn a new technology. I like
    helping people, which is why I'm here, and I think the record shows
    that I give a lot of good advice.

    What really annoys me is when people who have obviously just been told
    by their boss to "go write this as a Cocoa app", instead of taking a
    week or two (or three) to learn the technology, immediately run to the
    mailing lists to teach them Cocoa programming and design their code
    for them.


previous month may 2008 next month
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  
Go to today